{"text_format":"3","workbook":"xlsx","n_sheets":5,"sheets":["Overall Score","Legal Issues","Paper Style","Paper Evaluation","Parameters"],"not_rendered":{"defined_names":1},"read":"whole","date_system":"1900"}

{"sheet":"Overall Score","index":0,"n_rows":20,"n_cols":3,"rows_kept":20,"merged":[[3,1,3,10],[4,1,4,10],[7,1,7,10],[8,1,8,10],[9,1,9,10],[18,0,18,1],[19,0,19,1]]}
["AACE® International"]
["Technical Paper Evaluation Criteria (TPEC)"]
["Rev 22: October 25, 2023"]
["Paper Title:"]
["Authors:"]
["Track:",null,"No:"]
["Level:","TBD"]
["TCM Chapter (Primary):","TBD"]
["TCM Chapter (Secondary):","TBD"]
["Recommendation:","TBD"]
["Review Complete for This Tab?",{"$f":"IF(IFERROR(FIND(\"TBD\",B7&B8&B10),0)>0,\"Not Complete - Check for TBD\",\"Complete\")","v":"Not Complete - Check for TBD"}]
["Adjusted % Similarity Index:",{"v":0,"d":"0.0%"}]
["Legal Issues",{"$f":"'Legal Issues'!D13","v":"Fail"}]
["Paper Style",{"$f":"'Paper Style'!D15","v":"Fail"}]
["Paper Evaluation",{"$f":"'Paper Evaluation'!E33","v":"Fail"}]
[]
[{"$f":"'Paper Evaluation'!C33","v":"Total Score"},{"$f":"'Paper Evaluation'!D33","v":0}]
[]
["OVERALL REVIEW COMPLETE?"]
[{"$f":"IF(IF(B11=\"Complete\",1,0)+IF('Legal Issues'!$C$14=\"Complete\",1,0)+IF('Paper Style'!$C$16=\"Complete\",1,0)+IF('Paper Evaluation'!$D$34=\"Complete\",1,0)<4,\"NO - Check Each Tab\",\"YES\")","v":"NO - Check Each Tab"}]

{"sheet":"Legal Issues","index":1,"n_rows":14,"n_cols":5,"rows_kept":14}
[{"$f":"'Overall Score'!B4","v":0}]
[]
["Conference & Expo Technical Paper Guidelines Reference","Legal Issues","Score",null,"Comment"]
[3.1,"Plagiarism","TBD",{"$f":"IF(C4=\"Pass\",0,1)","v":1}]
[3.2,"Ownership of Figures","TBD",{"$f":"IF(C5=\"Pass\",0,1)","v":1}]
[3.3,"Overuse of Quotations","TBD",1]
[3.4,"Confidentiality Issues","TBD",1]
[3.5,"Intellectual Property","TBD",{"$f":"IF(C8=\"Pass\",0,1)","v":1}]
[3.6,"Anti-Competitiveness Issues","TBD",1]
[3.7,"Commercialism","TBD",1]
[3.8,"U.S. Economic Sanctions","TBD",1]
[null,"Total Areas of Concern",null,{"$f":"SUM(D4:D11)","v":8}]
[null,"Pass/Fail",null,{"$f":"IF(D12>0,\"Fail\",\"Pass\")","v":"Fail"}]
[null,"Review Complete for This Tab?",{"$f":"IF(IFERROR(FIND(\"TBD\",C4&C5&C6&C7&C8&C9&C10&C11),0)>0,\"Not Complete - Check for TBD\",\"Complete\")","v":"Not Complete - Check for TBD"}]

{"sheet":"Paper Style","index":2,"n_rows":16,"n_cols":5,"rows_kept":16,"merged":[[0,0,0,4]]}
[{"$f":"'Overall Score'!B4","v":0}]
[]
["Conference & Expo Technical Paper Guidelines Reference","Paper Style Issues","Score",null,"Comment"]
[4.1,"Conference & Expo Paper Template","TBD",{"$f":"IF(C4=\"Pass\",0,1)","v":1}]
[4.2,"Third Person Form Technical Writing Style","TBD",{"$f":"IF(C5=\"Pass\",0,1)","v":1}]
["Appendix A.3","Refer to AACE International Correctly","TBD",1]
["Appendix A.6","Capitalization","TBD",1]
[4.3,"Title","TBD",{"$f":"IF(C8=\"Pass\",0,1)","v":1}]
[4.4,"Abstract","TBD",1]
[4.5,"Table of Contents","TBD",1]
[4.6,"Caption All Tables and Figures","TBD",1]
[4.7,"Number Equations","TBD",1]
[4.9,"List of References Format","TBD",{"$f":"IF(C13=\"Pass\",0,1)","v":1}]
[null,"Total Areas of Concern",null,{"$f":"SUM(D4:D13)","v":10}]
[null,"Pass/Fail",null,{"$f":"IF(D14>0,\"Fail\",\"Pass\")","v":"Fail"}]
[null,"Review Complete for This Tab?",{"$f":"IF(IFERROR(FIND(\"TBD\",C4&C5&C6&C7&C8&C9&C10&C11&C12&C13),0)>0,\"Not Complete - Check for TBD\",\"Complete\")","v":"Not Complete - Check for TBD"}]

{"sheet":"Paper Evaluation","index":3,"n_rows":35,"n_cols":5,"rows_kept":35,"merged":[[4,2,4,5],[5,2,5,5],[6,2,6,5],[7,2,7,5],[8,2,8,5],[9,2,9,5],[11,2,11,5],[12,2,12,5],[13,2,13,5],[14,2,14,5],[15,2,15,5],[16,2,16,5],[18,2,18,5],[19,2,19,5],[20,2,20,5],[21,2,21,5],[22,2,22,5],[23,2,23,5],[25,2,25,5],[26,2,26,5],[27,2,27,5],[28,2,28,5],[29,2,29,5],[30,2,30,5],[35,0,35,5]]}
[{"$f":"'Overall Score'!B4","v":0}]
[]
["Conference & Expo Technical Paper Guidelines Reference",null,"Paper Evaluation","Score"]
[5.1,"Score","Subject Matter Competency",null,{"$f":"IF(D4>=4,\"Pass\", \"Fail\")","v":"Fail"}]
[null,6,"The paper is technically correct; addresses the subject matter clearly and thoroughly; and effectively communicates all technical aspects of the paper."]
[null,5,"The paper is technically correct; addresses the subject matter clearly and thoroughly; but may communicate some technical aspects of the subject more effectively than others."]
[null,4,"The paper is technically correct; addresses the subject matter clearly, but perhaps not as thoroughly as it should; and communicates the technical aspects of the paper adequately."]
[null,3,"The paper may have issues with technical accuracy or in addressing specific portions of the subject matter; or may be lacking in explaining the technical aspects of the paper."]
[null,2,"The paper may indicate confusion about the technical subject matter; may neglect important parts of the subject matter; or may be lacking in explaining the technical aspects of the paper."]
[null,1,"The paper suggests a lack of knowledge of the technical subject matter; may neglect important parts of the subject matter; or may be lacking in explaining the technical aspects of the paper."]
[5.2,"Score","Organization and Development",null,{"$f":"IF(D11>=4,\"Pass\", \"Fail\")","v":"Fail"}]
[null,6,"The paper is clearly organized; and reinforced with developed reasoning, examples, figures, and other supporting information."]
[null,5,"The paper is clearly organized and developed; but may lack extensive supporting information."]
[null,4,"The paper is adequately organized; and generally reinforced with supporting information."]
[null,3,"The paper is in-adequately organized; and/or may present generalizations or conclusions without appropriate supporting examples or information."]
[null,2,"The paper is weakly organized; and/or provides little or no supporting information."]
[null,1,"The paper is disorganized and underdeveloped; and provides little or no supporting information."]
[5.3,"Score","Syntax and Command of Language",null,{"$f":"IF(D18>=4,\"Pass\", \"Fail\")","v":"Fail"}]
[null,6,"The paper has a fluent style; demonstrates syntactic variety and clear command of language and vocabulary."]
[null,5,"The paper provides some syntactic variety; and demonstrates command of language and vocabulary."]
[null,4,"The paper demonstrates adequate use of syntax and vocabulary."]
[null,3,"The paper shows limited control of syntax and vocabulary."]
[null,2,"The paper shows inadequate control of syntax and vocabulary."]
[null,1,"The paper lacks basic control of syntax and vocabulary."]
[5.4,"Score","Grammar, Usage, and Mechanics",null,{"$f":"IF(D25>=4,\"Pass\", \"Fail\")","v":"Fail"}]
[null,6,"The paper contains no errors in grammar, usage, and mechanics."]
[null,5,"The paper is generally free from errors in grammar, usage, and mechanics."]
[null,4,"The paper may contain a few errors, but generally demonstrates control of grammar, usage, and mechanics."]
[null,3,"The paper contains an accumulation of errors that sometimes interferes with the understanding of the subject matter."]
[null,2,"The paper contains numerous errors that frequently interfere with the understanding of the subject matter."]
[null,1,"The paper contains serious and persistent errors in grammar, usage, and mechanics that severely interfere with understanding the subject matter."]
[]
[null,null,"Total Score",{"$f":"SUM(D4,D11,D18,D25)","v":0},{"$f":"IF(AND(E4=\"Pass\",E11=\"Pass\",E18=\"Pass\",E25=\"Pass\"),\"Pass\",\"Fail\")","v":"Fail"}]
[null,null,"Review Complete for This Tab?",{"$f":"IF(D4=\"\",\"Not Complete - Check for Missing Score\",IF(D11=\"\",\"Not Complete - Check for Missing Score\",IF(D18=\"\",\"Not Complete - Check for Missing Score\",IF(D25=\"\",\"Not Complete - Check for Missing Score\",\"Complete\"))))","v":"Not Complete - Check for Missing Score"}]
["Comments:",null,null,{"$f":"IF(E33=\"Fail\",\"Please provide reasons for failing in the comment field below.\",\"\")","v":"Please provide reasons for failing in the comment field below."}]

{"sheet":"Parameters","index":4,"n_rows":40,"n_cols":2,"rows_kept":40,"hidden":true}
["TBD","TBD"]
["ACCEPTED - The paper is recommended for publication in the AACE International Transactions and presentation at the Conference & Expo.","0.0. General Reference"]
["ACCEPTED WITH OPTIONAL REVISE/RESUBMIT - The paper may optionally be revised to address the review comments, but even as-is it is recommended for publication in the AACE International Transactions and presentation at the Conference & Expo.","1.1. Definition of Total Cost Management"]
["CONDITIONALLY ACCEPTED PENDING MINOR REVISIONS/RESUBMIT - This paper will be recommended for publication in the AACE International Transactions and presentation at the Conference & Expo, provided the review comments and edits are addressed.","1.2. Purpose and Uses of the TCM Framework"]
["REVISE/RESUBMIT - Please revise the paper to address the review comments identified in this scoring document, and resubmit.","1.3. Organization of the TCM Framework"]
["REWRITE - The paper is not sufficiently developed and cannot be considered for this year’s conference. Please revise and resubmit for next year.","1.4. Key Introductory Concepts for Total Cost Management"]
["REJECTED - The paper cannot be accepted because of significant misalignment with AACE recommended practices or the TCM Framework.","2.1. Basis of Total Cost Management Processes"]
["REJECTED - The paper cannot be accepted because of legal issues.","2.2. Total Cost Management Process Map"]
[null,"2.3. Strategic Asset Management Process Map"]
[null,"2.4. Project Control Process Map"]
[null,"3.1. Requirements Elicitation and Analysis"]
[null,"3.2. Asset Planning"]
[null,"3.3. Investment Decision Making"]
[null,"4.1. Project Implementation"]
[null,"5.1. Asset Cost Accounting"]
[null,"5.2. Asset Performance Measurement"]
[null,"6.1. Asset Performance Assessment"]
[null,"6.2. Asset Change Management"]
[null,"6.3. Asset Historical Database Management"]
[null,"6.4. Forensic Performance Assessment"]
[null,"7.1. Project Scope and Execution Strategy Development"]
[null,"7.2. Schedule Planning and Development"]
[null,"7.3. Cost Estimating and Budgeting"]
[null,"7.4. Resource Planning"]
[null,"7.5. Value Analysis and Engineering"]
[null,"7.6. Risk Management"]
[null,"7.7. Procurement Planning"]
[null,"8.1. Project Control Plan Implementation"]
[null,"9.1. Project Cost Accounting"]
[null,"9.2. Progress and Performance Measurement"]
[null,"10.1. Project Performance Assessment"]
[null,"10.2. Forecasting"]
[null,"10.3. Change Management"]
[null,"10.4. Project Historical Database Management"]
[null,"11.1. The Enterprise in Society"]
[null,"11.2. People and Performance Management"]
[null,"11.3. Information Management"]
[null,"11.4. Quality and Quality Management"]
[null,"11.5. Value Management and Value Improving Practices (VIPs)"]
[null,"11.6. Environment, Health, and Safety Management"]